| 2012 | |||
| Erlin Santos | SO. | Western | |
| Shawn Hunter | FR. | NOC-Enid | |
| JR Head | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Dusty Harper | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Brandon Ruiz | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Christian Faulkner | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Shawn McAndrews | SO. | Western | |
| Raphael Pena | FR. | Western | |
| Hazel Werson | SO. | Western | |
| Marty Dunlap | SO. | Western | |
| Travis Caraway | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Elvis Rodnqua | SO. | Western | |
| 2013 | |||
| Brandon Martin | FR. | NOC-Enid | |
| Sherman La Crus | SO. | Western | |
| Rahul Badve | FR. | Redlands | |
| Petr Sila | SO. | Redlands | |
| Eddie Keiffer | FR. | Murray State | |
| Jared Sterling | SO. | Murray State | |
| Brance Kahle | FR. | Murray State | |
| Noel Nevarez | SO. | Murray State | |
| Jacob Martinez | FR. | Murray State | |
| Bradley Horn | FR. | Murray State | |
| Eddie Broll | SO. | Murray State | |
| Josh Ingram | FR. | Murray State | |
| 2014 | |||
| Colt Pickens | Murray State College | ||
| Nik Gifford | FR. | NOC-Enid | |
| Nick Yoning | FR. | NOC-Enid | |
| Brandon Grimsley | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Korbin Polston | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Trenton Dupre | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Jon Chidester | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Lane Paul | Murray State College | ||
| Daniel Arthur | Murray State College | ||
| Jerame Littell | NOC-Enid | ||
| Russ Colgan | NOC-Enid | ||
| 2015 | |||
| Travis Spinney | FR. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Victor Draijer | SO. | Redlands | |
| Nick Yoning | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Nik Gifford | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Austin Hagy | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Andres Ramos | FR. | Murray State College | |
| Fernando Garcia | FR. | Murray State College | |
| Jashua Anthony | FR. | Western | |
| Christian Tapia | FR. | Western | |
| Justin Ellison | SO. | Western | |
| Carlos Pimentel | FR. | Western | |
| MVP | Marlor Villafana | SO. | Western |
| 2016 | |||
| Anthony Alvarez | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Travis Spinney | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Ryan Lujan-Leonard | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Ted Wisdon | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Jared Flores | FR. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Tanner Andrews | SO. | Western | |
| Carlos Primental | SO. | Western | |
| Bryan Hernandez | FR. | Western | |
| Raul Mercado | FR. | Western | |
| Taylor Avila | FR. | Western | |
| Frankely Gonzales | SO. | Western | |
| MVP | Blake Clanton | SO. | Western |
| 2017 | |||
| Preston Whitten | SO. | Carl Albert | |
| Griffen Keller | FR. | NOC - Enid | |
| Carlos Andjuar | SO. | NOC - Enid | |
| TJ Black | FR. | NOC - Enid | |
| Matt Conerly | FR. | NOC - Enid | |
| Colton Thompson | SO. | NOC - Enid | |
| Troy Black | FR. | Murray State | |
| Grant Macciocchi | SO. | Murray State | |
| Ricky Silvestri | FR. | Murray State | |
| Sean Dixson | SO. | Murray State | |
| Ryan Harrel | FR. | Murray State | |
| Dillon Lawrence | SO. | Murray State | |
| 2018 | |||
| Christian Martin | FR. | Western | |
| Junior Martina | FR. | Western | |
| Avelito Feliz | SO. | Western | |
| Danny Perez | SO. | Western | |
| Caleb Upshaw | FR. | Western | |
| Chris Hanson | SO. | NOC - Enid | |
| Wesley O'Neil | SO. | NOC - Enid | |
| Clayton Peterson | FR. | NOC - Enid | |
| Rowdy Reihs | SO. | NOC - Enid | |
| E.J. Taylor | FR. | NOC - Enid | |
| Brendon Woelfle | FR. | NOC - Enid | |
| Braxton Douthit | FR. | NOC - Enid | |
| 2019 | Tre Obregon | SO. | Carl Albert |
| Morgan Crenshaw | SO. | Carl Albert | |
| Austin Dahlenburg | SO. | Redlands | |
| Holden Tate | FR. | Redlands | |
| Joshua Detweiler | SO. | Redlands | |
| Garrett Misenheimer | SO. | NOC Enid | |
| Stevie Owings | FR. | NOC Enid | |
| Alec Buonasera | FR. | NOC Enid | |
| D.J. Calvert | SO. | NOC Enid | |
| Jarrett Sweeney | SO. | NOC Enid | |
| Clay Lockett | SO. | NOC Enid | |
| MVP | E.J. Taylor | SO. | NOV Enid |
| 2021 | Mac Moody | SO. | Carl Albert |
| Demias Jimmerson | FR. | National Park | |
| Calyn Halvorson | FR. | NOC-Enid | |
| Wesley Featherston | FR. | UA Rich Mountain | |
| Drake Fontenot | FR. | UA Rich Mountain | |
| Jhonny Felix | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Rodrigo Montero | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Johnny Urena | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Juan Pimental | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |